Treadmill Reviews Get the best value for your money.

ProForm ZE9 vs. the NordicTrack AudioStrider 990

Reader's Question on what is a better value, the ProForm ZE9 vs. the NordicTrack AudioStrider 990.

Dear Mr. Waters,

I enjoyed reading your reviews of elliptical trainers.  I have been distressing about buying an elliptical to get in shape.  A little bit about myself.  I'm a tall guy, 6'6" tall, built like a baseball player (235 lbs), but I'm out of shape.  Once upon a time, about a decade ago, I had a great routine involving running and using an elliptical.  I'd like to get back on the elliptical again, and am shopping for one.  I anticipate that I'll be using it an hour a day for about 2 months (to get in shape for skiing), and then a few times a week after that.

I am comparing two models.  My preferred is the Proform ZE9, which is on sale at Dicks for $799.  And the other is the Nordic Track Audiostrider 990 Pro, which is $990 at Sears.  They are very similar, except the Proform has a longer stride.

My only concern is that I cannot find a review of the Proform ZE9 anywhere!  I'd like to do my homework to make sure I get a decent product, and I'd like to hear from others to make a decision as to whether to buy the warranty.

Can you help me?  Is the ZE9 a newer version of a comparable piece of equipment?  Would you recommend the extended warranty?  Any advice you can give would be greatly appreciated!

Thanks in advance!

Response:

Regarding the durability of these machines.  They both qualify as budget models.  They have a decent track record, but these are not heavy duty machines.  It looks like the ZE9 is the better value.

If you have a Dick's in your area I also recommend you check out the Sole E25.  It cost $999, but has a 3-year parts warranty.  It has an incline feature, but it is manual.  All the Sole ellipticals have a very good service record.  The quality of the Sole E25 surpasses both the NordicTrack and the ProForm.

I hope that helps.
Fred